Resources & Insights

Why Faith-Based Investing Is Not the Same As Playing it Safe

If you’ve ever thought about aligning your investments with your faith, there’s a good chance one worry stopped you cold: Won’t I have to give up growth to do it?

It’s the most common question we hear at Stewardship Investments, and it’s a fair one. Somewhere along the way, “faith-based investing” got filed next to “conservative,” “cautious,” and “playing it safe,” as if putting your values into your portfolio automatically means dialing down your ambitions for it. Let’s explore that assumption, because it isn’t how Biblically Responsible Investing actually works.

Where the “You’ll Sacrifice Returns” Idea Comes From

The myth has an understandable origin. For a long time, “values-based” and “ethical” investing were treated as a niche corner of the market, often associated with a short list of funds that felt limiting. People pictured a tiny, boxed-in menu of options and reasonably assumed that fewer choices had to mean weaker performance.

But Biblically Responsible Investing (BRI) isn’t a single fund or a defensive posture. It’s a screening approach applied to an actively managed, diversified portfolio. Screening out a category of companies is not the same as retreating to safety. Your portfolio is still built to pursue growth over your time horizon, still diversified across the market, and still adjusted as conditions change. The values filter tells us what belongs in the portfolio; it doesn’t decide how ambitious that portfolio can be.

Faith-Based Investing Is a Values Filter, Not a Risk Setting

Here’s the distinction that clears up most of the confusion. “Playing it safe” describes your risk level, how much volatility you’re willing to accept in pursuit of your goals. Faith-based investing describes your criteria, which companies you’re willing to own in the first place. Those are two separate dials.

You can hold a growth-oriented, faith-aligned portfolio. You can also hold a more conservative one. Biblically Responsible Investing works across the whole range, because the screen sits on top of your strategy rather than replacing it. When we build a plan for your family, your risk level still comes from the same things it always should: your goals, your time horizon, and how much market movement you’re comfortable with along the way.

How Biblically Responsible Investing Actually Works

At Stewardship Investments, every portfolio we manage screens out companies that profit from activities that conflict with biblical values, such as abortion, pornography, gambling, and exploitation. What remains is still a broad, diversified universe of companies across sectors and sizes.

From there, our approach looks a lot like any thoughtful, actively managed strategy. We diversify. We monitor market trends and adjust as needed. We keep your plan tied to your time horizon and your goals. The screening happens first, and then the ordinary work of prudent investing continues from there. If you’d like to see it in motion, our video What Is Biblically Responsible Investing? walks through the process in plain language.

This is also why the “Does BRI outperform” question is the wrong frame. No responsible advisor can promise that any strategy, faith-based or otherwise, comes out ahead. What we can say is that aligning your portfolio with your convictions does not require you to abandon a growth-minded, diversified approach. The two can coexist.

Values and Discipline Are Not Opposites

There’s a reason this resonates with families who follow a Dave Ramsey style of building wealth. Ramsey’s philosophy is rooted in discipline, consistency, a long-term mindset, and treating money as a stewardship responsibility rather than an end in itself. Biblically Responsible Investing fits naturally inside that worldview. It asks you to be intentional about what you own, in the same spirit that disciplined investing asks you to be intentional about how you invest.

Staying invested through market ups and downs, keeping a long time horizon, and avoiding emotional decisions matter just as much in a faith-aligned portfolio as in any other. Your values shape the holdings; your discipline shapes the outcome over time.

What This Means for Your Portfolio

Let’s be candid about the part that matters most. All investing involves risk, including the potential loss of the money you invest. No strategy, including Biblically Responsible Investing, can guarantee a profit or remove the risk of loss, and past performance is never a promise of future results. Anyone who tells you otherwise, faith-based or not, is overstating what any investment can do.

What faith-based investing offers is not a shortcut to stronger returns and not a retreat into caution. It’s the ability to pursue your financial goals with a portfolio that reflects your convictions, built and managed with the same care and diversification you’d expect from any prudent plan. For many of the families we serve, that alignment is the whole point. Their money is doing its work without working against the things they believe.

So, no, faith-based investing is not the same as playing it safe. It’s a way of being deliberate about your values and your growth at the same time. You don’t have to choose between them.

Are You Ready to Grow With Purpose?

Curious whether a biblically responsible portfolio fits your family’s goals? Stewardship Investments, Inc. can help you start planning with purpose. Get to know the team walking alongside you and read more about our firm. You can also watch more on our YouTube channel.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does faith-based investing mean I have to sacrifice returns? 

Not by design. Biblically Responsible Investing applies a values screen to an actively managed, diversified portfolio. The screen decides which companies belong in the portfolio, while your growth potential and risk level come from your goals and time horizon. That said, all investing carries risk, and no approach can guarantee a particular result.

Does Biblically Responsible Investing outperform regular investing? 

No advisor can honestly promise that any strategy outperforms another, and we won’t. What we can say is that aligning your portfolio with your faith does not require giving up a growth-minded, diversified approach. Performance depends on many factors, and past results never guarantee future ones.

What exactly does Biblically Responsible Investing screen out? 

BRI screens out companies that profit from activities that conflict with biblical values, such as abortion, pornography, gambling, and exploitation. What remains is still a broad, diversified set of companies to build a portfolio from.

Is faith-based investing only for very conservative investors? 

No. The values screen is separate from your risk level. You can hold a growth-oriented faith-aligned portfolio or a more conservative one. We set your risk level based on your goals, your time horizon, and your comfort with market movement.

How do I get started with a faith-aligned plan? 

The first step is a conversation. You can reach our team through our website to talk through your goals and see whether Biblically Responsible Investing fits your family.

About Stewardship Investments, Inc.

Stewardship Investments is a fee-only Registered Investment Advisor serving generous Christian families across Minnesota, North Dakota, North Carolina, and Florida. Established in 2007, the firm provides biblically responsible investing and holistic financial planning designed to help clients grow wealth, manage taxes, and give generously. The team operates on the foundational belief that God owns it all, offering a mission-driven alternative to secular advising that helps families steward their resources with wisdom, purpose, and an eternal perspective.

Investment advisory services carry risk, including the potential loss of principal. This article is for educational purposes and is not individualized investment advice.

Investment advisory services are offered by Stewardship Investments, a Securities and Exchange Commission Registered Investment Advisor. Opinions expressed are as of the current date and subject to change without notice, and data may be obtained from third-party sources we believe are reliable. Stewardship Investments shall not be responsible for any trading decisions, damages, or other losses resulting from, or related to, the information, data, analyses or opinions contained herein or their use, which do not constitute investment advice, are provided as of the date written, are provided solely for informational purposes and therefore are not an offer to buy or sell a security. This commentary is for informational purposes only and has not been tailored to suit any individual. References to specific securities or investment options should not be considered an offer to purchase or sell that specific investment.

Resources & Insights

Related Articles From Our Stewardship Journal

Should You Pay Off Your Mortgage in Retirement? A Real Family’s Plan

Should You Pay Off Your Mortgage in Retirement? A Real Family’s Plan

Should you pay off your mortgage in retirement? If most of your savings sit in 401(k)s and IRAs, the way you pay off the house can raise your tax bill, your Medicare premiums and the cost of the payoff itself.

In this follow-up video, we return to Steve and Karen, a couple with about $2 million saved and a goal of spending $11,500 a month, to show how Social Security timing, Roth conversions and their two mortgages all draw from the same yearly budget of taxable income.

Client Login Portal

Right Capital

Right Capital is our financial planning software. It’s your one-stop hub for your financial life—bringing together your accounts, your financial plan, and more in one place. Accounts are securely aggregated to give you a clear, complete view.

Fidelity

Fidelity is where you view your investment accounts, statements, and tax forms securely.

FREE INVESTING GUIDE

Is Your Portfolio Aligned With Your Faith?

Meet Our Founder

Alexis Vowell

Client Service Manager
Alexis joined Stewardship Investments in April 2026 with a passion for helping clients steward their resources in a way that honors the Lord and creates a lasting Kingdom impact. With nearly four years of experience in the financial planning industry, she supports clients through onboarding and account maintenance with integrity, care, and a servant’s heart.
She holds both bachelor’s and master’s degrees from Mississippi State University. In 2023, she was recognized as an author of a Distinguished Manuscript for her research supporting family-owned agritourism businesses in Mississippi.
Alexis is currently pursuing the CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER™ professional designation and is committed to continual growth to better serve clients and colleagues with excellence.
She resides in Weir, Mississippi, with her husband and is actively involved in their church, where she leads music and organizes community outreach efforts. Outside of work and church, she enjoys gardening, raising livestock, and spending time with her family

Meet Our Founder

Greg Towner

Chief Investment Officer
An incredible addition to our team, Greg leverages his dynamic background in the industry, designing investment portfolios for Stewardship Investments. As a Chief Investment Officer, Greg’s investment process emphasizes a rules-based approach with a focus on high-quality assets, risk management, and blending both fundamental and technical analysis.
Greg obtained his Master of Business Administration with a concentration in Finance from the University of Central Florida, a bachelor’s degree from the University of Mount Union, and holds the Chartered Financial Analyst® and Chartered Market Technician® designations. Greg lives in Raleigh, North Carolina, with his wife, Faith, an aerial circus instructor who performs all over the East Coast. When he takes a break from studying the market, Greg can often be found riding his bicycle on the local greenway trails or walking in the park with Faith.

Meet Our Founder

Brian Boughner

CFA Charterholder & Chartered Market Technician
Collaborating with Stewardship Investments to enhance our ability to effectively cater to our clients, Brian’s proficiency empowers us to remain at the forefront of technological advancements, foster business growth, and stay up to date in our industry.
Right at the very top of the biggest bull market, Brian began his investment career in 1999, during which he has helped his clients manage their investments through the 9/11 terrorist attack, two equity bear markets, a housing bust, a credit implosion, and the COVID pandemic. Brian and his wife, Jeanne, have a daughter, Selah, and a son, Noah, who attend The Village Church in Greenville and are very active in the community. Brian’s involvement includes Leadership Greenville, board trustee of the South Carolina Children’s Theatre, and Project Host. A lover of the outdoors, Brian regularly bikes, runs, and backpacks the mountain trails here in the southeast. He is also very passionate about the upstate art scene and has performed in productions at many of the local theaters.

Meet Our Founder

Randall Neighbour

RICP® APMA®
Randall owns and operates Kingdom Wealth Management in Houston, Texas, an affiliate company of Stewardship Investments. Randall is an ordained minister and served as the President of TOUCH Outreach Ministries in a full-time capacity for 18 years prior to entering into the financial services industry in 2010. In this role, Randall saw the powerful, life-changing impact financial resources can have when used strategically.
Randall and his wife, Etna, were married in 1986 and own a restored bungalow located in the historic Heights near downtown Houston, Texas. They serve as small group leaders at Antioch Church, Central Houston. Randall enjoys making handwriting instruments on his wood lathe and playing with the family’s golden retrievers. Most of all, Randall and Etna find their greatest joy in strategic charitable giving.

Meet Our Founder

Stephen Harvey

Client Service and Operations Specialist
Stephen’s professional background spans financial planning support and mortgage lending, where he has worked closely with individuals and families. He holds a degree in Political Science from California Baptist University, a foundation that sharpened his analytical skills and strengthened his ability to serve families with care and clarity.
Stephen is a devoted believer whose faith informs both his personal life and professional values. He is married and the proud father of two beautiful daughters. He lives in Temple, Texas, where he remains active in his local church and community. Stephen is committed to serving families with integrity, consistency, and a genuine desire to support Stewardship’s mission.

Meet Our Founder

Hailey Heppner

Client Care Specialist
Part of Stewardship Investments since 2024, Hailey holds a bachelor’s degree in business and accounting and has developed her professional career working for small businesses in operations and administrative roles.
Hailey deeply values work that allows her to serve others and that also aligns with her faith in the Lord. She assists in various client service tasks like contributions and withholdings, as well as some of the marketing for Stewardship Investments.
Living in Central California with their daughter, Hailey, and her husband, Bryce, enjoy hosting friends, playing volleyball, and spending time outside together. Active members of their church community, serving with music, childcare, and their Young Adults group, Hailey and Bryce also love to read, and recently began hosting a book group to encourage discussion around some of their favorite reads.

Meet Our Founder

Tabitha Lundstrom

Chief Operating Officer
Tabitha joined Stewardship Investments in 2015 with the desire to be part of a team that empowers clients to make wise financial decisions. She has a background in tutoring and teaching, and previously served as church treasurer. Her enthusiasm for research and working with people led to a BS in Psychology from Bemidji State.
With nine years of experience in client services, Tabitha helps the team’s day-to-day operations run smoothly and efficiently. Leveraging her understanding of processes and procedures, she develops frameworks that streamline our operations so we can meet our clients’ needs with care and precision. Tabitha also collaborates with our compliance department to sustain our efforts to meet all industry guidelines and regulations.
In her free time, Tabitha enjoys reading, gardening, and spending time outdoors. She makes her home in Bemidji with her husband, Jonathan, and their two daughters.

Meet Our Founder

Gracie Olson

Financial Advisor
Gracie grew up watching her father, Joseph, guide clients in using their wealth for eternal impact, inspiring her own passion for walking alongside individuals in their financial journeys. After nearly five years of training under Joseph and Matthew and gaining experience in multiple roles at Stewardship Investments, Gracie has stepped into the role of Wealth Manager. She believes true financial success is not just about accumulating wealth but about using it wisely to bless others and further God’s Kingdom. One of her guiding verses is 1 Timothy 6:18-19: “Command them to do good, to be rich in good deeds, and to be generous and willing to share. In this way, they will lay up treasure for themselves as a firm foundation for the coming age, so that they may take hold of the life that is truly life.”
Gracie finds great fulfillment in helping families align their financial decisions with their faith so their resources reflect their values and create a meaningful impact for the Kingdom and generations to come. She and her husband, Preston, live in Bemidji, Minnesota, with their daughter, Daisy Joy. They are actively involved in their church, multiple Bible studies, and the local community. In her free time, Gracie enjoys spending time on the lake, camping, playing pickleball, and golfing. During the winter months, she loves playing board games and reading.

Education/Certification:

Meet Our Founder

Matthew Myrick

Partner, Financial Advisor
Matthew joined the Stewardship Investments team as a wealth management professional in 2018 and became a partner of the company in 2023. He previously served as a Financial Aid Director in Christian higher education for nearly four years. His background includes communications consulting, business development, teaching business classes as an adjunct professor, and E-commerce marketing.
Matt believes in biblical stewardship and feels that Psalm 24:1 perfectly illustrates how believers should understand their money: “The earth is the Lord’s, and everything in it, the world, and all who live in it.” It is the foundation from which he helps his clients pursue their goals. Matt’s greatest desire for a client of Stewardship Investments is to see them find the life they’re seeking by coming alongside them with the heart of a teacher and friend. He thrives on relationships and feels that true fellowship does not exist without genuine connection.
Matt is married to his high school sweetheart, Shelbi, and together they have two sons, Hudson and Harrison. In his free time, Matt enjoys being outdoors, hunting, fishing, and hiking.

Education/Certification:

Meet Our Founder

Joseph Nelson

Founder, CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER®, CFP®

Joseph founded Stewardship Investments in 2007, with a strong desire to come alongside people to help them invest wisely. His mission is to assist people with comprehensive financial planning, so all aspects of their finances align with a biblical foundation. It’s his passion that each client feels confident in their financial journey. Proverbs 21:5 states, “Good planning and hard work lead to prosperity, but hasty shortcuts lead to poverty.”
Joseph worked for eight years with a Bible translation mission, spending most of that time in Kenya managing project funds. During this time, he saw firsthand the impact financial resources can have when used strategically for the Kingdom.
A resident of southern Florida, spending his summers in Minnesota, Joseph and his wife, Carol, have three kids and three in-laws. They love spending time with their seven grandkids, and Joseph enjoys photography, time at the beach, pickleball, cooking, running, and reading.

To view more about Joseph’s background, please visit FINRA’s BrokerCheck website.

Education/Certification: